| Rank | School | 1st Place Votes |
| 1 | Liberty University | (5) |
| 2 | California Baptist University | (6) |
| 3 | Lindenwood University - St. Charles | |
| 4 | University of Maryland / Baltimore County | |
| 5 | Notre Dame College | (1) |
| 6 | Southern Illinois University - Edwardsville | |
| 7 | Grand Valley State University | |
| 8 | The Apprentice School | |
| 9 | Lindenwood University - Belleville | |
| 10 | Marion Military Institute | |
| 11 | University of Central Florida | |
| 12 | McKendree University | |
| 13 | Mercer University | |
| 14 | Middle Tennessee State University | |
| 15 | Massachusetts Institute of Technology | |
| 16 | California State University - Sacramento | (1) |
| 17 | United States Naval Academy Prep | |
| 18 | United States Military Academy Prep | |
| 19 | West Chester University | |
| 20 | University of New Hampshire | |
| 21 | Amherst College | |
| 22 | Wichita State University | |
| 23 | Penn State University - DuBois | |
| 24 | Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute | |
| 25 | United States Air Force Academy Prep | |